Mohammad Al-Ubaydli’s blog

Free Software is a pricing innovation

Posted in People / organisations by Dr Mohammad Al-Ubaydli on April 12, 2006

I am fifty years behind the rest of the world, but I have finally discovered the joys of Peter Drucker’s books. The first book I read is “Innovation and Entrepreneurship”, from which I have been mulling on this insight from page 247 about Xerox and its invention of the photocopier:

One reason why patents on a copying machine ended up at a small, obscure company in Rochester, New York, then known as the Haloyd Company, rather than one of the big printing-machine manufacturers, was that none of the large established manufacturers saw any possibility of selling a copying machine. Their calculations showed that such a machine would have to sell for at least $4000. Nobody was going to pay such a sum for a copying machine when carbon paper cost practically nothing. Also, of course, to spend $4000 on a machine meant a capital-appropriations request, which had to go all the way up to the board of directors, accompanied by a calculation showing the return on investment, both of which seemed unimaginable for a gadget designed to help the secretary. The Haloid Company — the present Xerox — did a good deal of technical work to design the final machine. But its major contribution was in pricing. It did not sell the machine; it sold what the machine produced, copies. At five or ten cents a copy, there is no need for a capital-appropriations request. This is “petty-cash”, which the secretary can disburse without going upstairs. Pricing the Xerox machine at five cents a copy was the tru innovation.

It is wonderful to have something you have always felt be so beautifully expressed. The reason I liked handheld computers, and the reason I like open source software even more, is that these technologies are cheap enough at the start not to need a decision from upper management. While working as a doctor setting up a handheld computer project was easy – I just had to convince my clinical colleagues to buy their own machines, and we would work together. They were quick to agree because the cost of a device was low, and the benefit obvious. Rightly or wrongly, as doctors we were the equivalent of the secretaries, and saving their labours with handheld computers was not something management had interest nor ability to consider.

Open source software pushes the bar even lower. With any team that I work, I suggest that open source software may be useful, the direct beneficieries agree to give their time for the experiment, and we just get started. No appropriations request, no management deliberations, we just start. If things go well, we let management know of the early success and ask for institutional support. If not, we move on to the next experiment.

It is because of this decision-making process that proprietary software companies are caught off-guard by companies with open source software at the centre of their business model. Before they could concentrate their marketing efforts on convincing upper management that the expenditure is useful – the software did not have to be useful to the employees who ended up using it every day, but it had to have the right buzzwords that management would think it was a good solution. With open source software the end users are making the decision – and theirs is a much more intelligent and accountable process – and the marketing departments’ ovetures to upper management become expensive overheads rather than powerful assets.

We all benefit from this change is decision-making.

One Response

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. […] Peter Drucker also argued for social responsibility in business – and this was a contributing factor to the rise of the Free/Open Source Software movement. In this context – why should free software have to earn a profit on O’Reilly’s blog is worth a read, and another is Mohammad Al-Ubaydli’s Free Software is a pricing innovation. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: